Stockwoods acts as amicus curiae in important appeal regarding fee sharing agreements in national class actions

Stockwoods lawyers Brendan van Niejenhuis and Carlo Di Carlo acted as amicus curiae before the Ontario Court of Appeal in an important appeal (Bancroft-Snell v. VISA Canada et al., 2016 ONCA 896) that confirmed the scope of discretion judges have to approve or disallow fee sharing agreements and counsel’s fees in the class proceedings context.  The case dealt with a multi-jurisdictional class proceeding, where an alleged “copy-cat”  claim was commenced in one of the provinces duplicating the allegations already being advanced by a consortium of class counsel.  After class counsel reached  a settlement with one of the defendants, they entered  into a  fee sharing agreement with the counsel that commenced the “copy-cat” litigation, in exchange for the latter counsel agreeing to abandon their rival class action.

At the settlement approval motion, Perell J. declined to enforce the fee sharing agreement.  He also reduced class counsel’s fee by 10%.  Class counsel and the other party to the fee sharing agreement appealed this decision.  In a decision released today, the Court of Appeal dismissed this appeal, and largely agreed with the submissions by amicus concerning the court’s authority under the Class Proceedings Act to review such agreements and the discretion to reduce class counsel’s fees in this context, and permitting the motion judge’s discretion to stand on that basis.

As the Court’s judgment notes, the issue of fee sharing agreements entered into in the context of multi-jurisdictional proceedings is one that has concerned the class actions bar.  This decision provides important appellate guidance on the controversial issues that continue to arise in the national class action context.

A copy of the Court of Appeal’s reasons can be found here.

Stockwoods Recognized in Lexpert 2024

Ted Marrocco speaks to the Association of Business Immigration Lawyers about Privacy and Online Risk Management

Paul Le Vay, Brian Gover and Carlo di Carlo Recognized in List of Leading 500 Lawyers in Canada

RYANN ATKINS JOINS THE PARTNERSHIP AT STOCKWOODS

DECEMBER ISSUE OF THE STOCKWOODS ADMINISTRATIVE AND REGULATORY LAW CASE REVIEW 

Jury Returns Homicide Verdict in Soleiman Faqiri Inquest

STOCKWOODS PARTNERS SUCCESSFULLY APPEAL DEFAMATION JUDGMENT

Ted Marrocco discusses Digital Assets at the Ontario Bar Association

Andrea Gonsalves and Luisa Ritacca speak on Commissions Advocacy

Stockwoods partners participate in the OPD 18th Annual National Forum on Administrative Law and Practice

OCTOBER ISSUE OF THE STOCKWOODS ADMINISTRATIVE & REGULATORY LAW CASE REVIEW

Chambers Canada recognizes Stockwoods’ for professional excellence

Stockwoods listed in Best Lawyers Canada for 2024

JULY ISSUE OF THE STOCKWOODS ADMINISTRATIVE & REGULATORY LAW CASE REVIEW

Ted Marrocco speaks at the Toronto Lawyers Association “Top Tips for Advocates” series
- Find a Lawyer -